Libreboot, the free and open-source boot firmware project based on coreboot, has changed its approach to AI-generated code, replacing the complete ban from Libreboot 26.11 with a more flexible policy aimed at reducing AI involvement where practical.
In a statement, project founder Lhehaa Rhoeow explained that the former prohibition was unrealistic, especially because Libreboot depends on upstream projects that already accept AI-assisted contributions.
The new approach, called the “AI Slop Reduction Policy,” is intended to reduce AI-generated code through selective patch reversions, rewrites, and other measures without promising complete elimination.
One main obstacle is coreboot itself. Since Libreboot incorporates coreboot, which accepts AI-generated contributions, Libreboot already distributes firmware containing such code. The project argues that removing every AI-assisted change would require resources beyond its existing capabilities, potentially forcing it to keep extensive forks of upstream software.
As an example of the new policy in action, Libreboot recently reverted support for thinkpad_acpi after an AI-generated fix addressed WWAN and Bluetooth issues introduced by the upstream implementation. Consequently, automatic battery charge threshold configuration is no longer available through that integration, though users can still configure thresholds manually using ectool.
However, the policy also recognizes situations where AI-assisted development may benefit free software. One example is ongoing coreboot work to replace Intel’s proprietary Firmware Support Package on Kaby Lake hardware, potentially eliminating proprietary initialization components from systems like the ThinkPad T480.
Although Rhoeow suspects AI tools assisted this reverse-engineering work, he acknowledges this has not been confirmed. Nevertheless, he intends to incorporate the code into an upcoming Libreboot release if the implementation meets the project’s quality expectations.
The reasoning is simple: replacing proprietary firmware with freely licensed, maintainable code takes priority over rejecting useful work solely because AI tools may have been involved.
A similar exception applies to ReBIOS, a freely licensed Compatibility Support Module used with EDK2 for legacy BIOS compatibility. Despite extensive AI involvement in its development, Libreboot still recommends it as an alternative to proprietary implementations.
The project’s position remains strongly critical of generative AI, especially regarding code quality, developer skill development, and the growing maintenance burden on free software projects. However, the updated policy acknowledges that completely eliminating AI-generated code from a project with many upstream dependencies is not currently feasible.
For more details, see Libreboot’s announcement.
